NYT19980117.0042
NEWS
NEWSWIRE
The following editorial will appear in The New York Times, Sunday,
Jan. 18: Casey Martin, a 25-year-old professional golfer afflicted
with a circulatory disorder that hinders his ability to walk, has
sued the PGA Tour to force it to exempt him from one of professional
golf's basic rules. The rule says that, except for golfers over 50
on the Senior Tour, players must walk the course. Martin says he cannot
earn a livelihood in his chosen profession unless he can ride in a
cart. Martin is a first-class golfer with bright prospects. He was
Tiger Woods's teammate at Stanford, and when a judge's preliminary
injunction allowed him to play (and ride) in a PGA satellite event
last week, he went out and won the tournament with a 19-under-par
score of 269. We believe that Martin should be allowed to ride. We
also believe that the integrity of professional golf will not be hopelessly
corrupted if the PGA Tour bends its rules for him and for others with
similarly crippling diseases. That said, it must also be granted that
this is a complex matter, in both legal and sporting terms. Martin
has invoked the Americans With Disabilities Act, the first time a
professional athlete has done so. The verdict may utimately turn on
fine legal questions, like whether the PGA Tour is an employer, as
defined by the act, or a nonprofit association that simply arranges
and manages tournaments for self-employed golfers. But it is on the
level of common sense that we think this matter can and should be
resolved. The PGA Tour argues that the stamina involved in walking
five miles is an integral part of the game. Traditionalists also recall
that no exception was made for Ken Venturi, who nearly collapsed in
98-degree heat en route to victory in the United States Open, or for
Ben Hogan, who won the Open after recovering from a near-fatal car
crash. This is the old level-playing-field argument, and usually it
makes sense. But we side with our colleague Dave Anderson in believing
that it is the swing, not the stride, that defines a professional
golfer. Furthermore, the PGA Tour is never going to be inundated with
applications from afflicted walkers who possess professional swings
because such skills are rare in the population at large. An exception
for Casey Martin will not hurt the sport. It will make the PGA look
wise and compassionate. It will add diversity and interest to a game
that doesn't need to be any more dull or homogenous.